Thursday, May 22, 2008

What's the Real Issue?

Racism is not the issue in immigration. The real issue is economic forces.
-- Summary of post by Somasoul on Young Anabaptist Radicals


I agree that racism is sometimes a non sequitor. Yes, there are still real race issues that need to be dealt with, but if all we see is one issue, then we are not going to get to the full truth of the source-- or solution-- to any of the complex issues we have.

Yes, economics is certainly an issue. So is blatant prejudice. But, more often than not, what people are complaining about is a difference in culture, in worldview, in how we see reality.

Economics is one issue. Group A wants to maintain a certain lifestyle, while Group B wants to get just a taste of the lifestyle of the other. These two goals cannot both be reached. Since Group A has the power, they want to take the opportunity away from Group B to reach their goals.

But I think that English isn't a problem with economics, but culture. Group A wants to maintain the culture they grew up with, while some of Group B cannot learn the culture of Group A (and they probably wouldn't want to even if they could).

This is always the problem of the poor and outcast. They either have to surrender their culture and worldview and overcome their limitations or they will be denied a new and better life.

How is it that we can get Group A and B to talk instead of throwing stones at each other?

Steve K